Stuck between two guys? What do I do?

Go with what your heart tells you. If you love Ty, then you should be with him. I went out with a guy in 8th grade when I was in 9th, and it was hard and kind of weird at first, but I just got over it because I knew that I cared about him. Don't take the easy way out, if you love Ty, then he should be the one you're with. Don't settle for second best.